Your donor list is a CRM problem, not a newsletter problem

If everyone gets the same newsletter, look at the list underneath it first.

By Ed Nuñez, Fractional CMO

Updated

Your donor list is a CRM problem, not a newsletter problem

Contents

Most nonprofits I’ve worked with have one list. Donors, volunteers, event attendees, partners, board members, a few vendors and someone who signed a petition five years ago all get the same monthly email.

Then the team wonders why open rates are sliding and why donors don’t respond to the appeal. The newsletter usually isn’t the problem. The list is. (If the trouble is that everyone describes you differently, that’s a separate fix: see how nonprofits explain their work.)

Different people, different relationships

A first-time donor, a ten-year volunteer and a foundation program officer don’t want the same email. They have different relationships with you and different reasons to read.

Start by naming your audience groups. A typical set:

  • Donors, split by first-time, repeat and lapsed.
  • Volunteers, active and past.
  • Partners and funders.
  • Board and advisors.
  • People you serve, if you communicate with them by email.
  • General supporters: event attendees, petition signers, newsletter signups.

One person can belong to several groups. That’s fine, as long as your system knows it.

Keep consent with the contact

The question you should be able to answer for anyone in your database is simple: can I email this person, and about what?

That means recording, on each contact:

  • How they joined (donation, event, signup form, import).
  • What they agreed to receive (newsletter, appeals, volunteer updates).
  • When they opted out, and of what.

A spreadsheet export and re-import loses all of that. A CRM that stores it on the contact keeps it, no matter which list or campaign they end up in. Our comparison of the best CRM for startups covers the main tools, and most of it applies to nonprofits too.

Don’t confuse “lapsed” with “gone”

A donor who hasn’t given in two years is lapsed, not unsubscribed. They may come back with the right ask. Keep the two statuses separate: one says where they are in the relationship, the other says what they’ve agreed to receive. Merging them can quietly cut off future donations. The same goes for judging results: give each group time to respond before measuring campaign results.

Quiet the people who’ve stopped listening

People who haven’t opened anything in a long time hurt your delivery for everyone else. Instead of mailing them forever:

  1. Send a short re-engagement email or two.
  2. If there’s still no response, move them to a quiet segment that gets only your most important messages.
  3. Respect every unsubscribe immediately.

Where to start

  • List your audience groups on one page.
  • Check whether your CRM records how and when each contact joined.
  • Pick one group, often recent first-time donors, and write to them separately next month.

If your list has grown into one big pile, our email and lifecycle team can help sort it out. Deciding who should own this work is its own question; our guide to nonprofit marketing hire options compares the choices, and more guides live in our nonprofit marketing hub.

ShareLinkedIn