How to know if a campaign worked when donations lag

If you only judge a campaign by donations in the first week, you’ll cancel things that were working.

By Ed Nuñez, Fractional CMO

Updated

How to know if a campaign worked when donations lag

Contents

A campaign launches. The first week’s donations come in light. Someone asks whether it’s working. The real answer is often: too early to tell.

Giving decisions take time. People see an appeal, think about it, talk to a partner, wait for payday or year-end, and give later, often through a different door than the one you were watching.

Decide what success means before you launch

Write down, before anything goes out:

  • The goal: dollars, new donors, monthly donors, or renewed lapsed donors.
  • The time frame you’ll judge it over. Usually longer than a week.
  • The early signals you’ll watch in the meantime.
  • What result means keep going, adjust, or stop.

Agreeing on this up front saves a lot of second-guessing in week two. Events work the same way; see planning a nonprofit event.

Leading indicators to watch

These show up before donations do:

  • Email opens and clicks on the campaign messages.
  • Visits to the donation page, and how many people start the form.
  • New email signups during the campaign.
  • Shares, replies and comments from supporters.
  • Direct and branded search traffic to your site.

If these rise and donations follow later, the campaign is doing its job.

Ask the simplest question

Ask donors how they found you. A single “How did you hear about us?” field on the donation form is enough; our local marketing guide shows the same habit for small businesses, and donors will tell you things your analytics can’t. Answers are only useful if they’re stored on the contact, which is a nonprofit donor CRM question.

Look back at the right time

Review the campaign at the end of the time frame you set, not before. Compare results to the target, read the “how did you hear” answers, and note what you’d repeat next time.

Our analytics and attribution team sets up measurement that matches how donors actually give. For who should own campaigns in the first place, see nonprofit marketing hire options, and more guides live in our nonprofit marketing hub.

ShareLinkedIn